You know that sensation of falling while you’re falling asleep? Have they ever tried dropping comatose or brain dead people to see if it wakes them up? In a safe way, like raised 1 foot off a bed in a hoist and fall softly onto a cushion.
Could you imagine being “locked in” with locked in syndrome and people around you decide to make you “fall”?
Yeah, you’re right. Roller coasters might be better.
It worked in Inception, so I don’t see any reason it wouldn’t work here.
Legit made me laugh!
This article leaves me asking many questions.
If I were her and felt like I had “conquered death,” I would want to find out how all those neurotoxins ended up in my lymphatic system.
Does anybody else in my immediate circle also have them in theirs? Because if they didn’t come from the environment and ifs not a question of where did they come from, it might be a question of who did they come from.
Some part of her deep inside, must felt the bump, and realized:
She can’t afford the ambulance.
The case is from India, In India ambulances are generally very cheap in fact in some parts they are free, subsidized by the government.
When turning it off and back on doesn’t work, sometime percussive maintenance is the key.
deleted by creator
Percussive maintenance strikes again
Had a TV growing up that we kept a large pot on the top of for when it went to static. We’d slam the top of the TV with it. No idea where that TV went but that pot is in my kitchen now.
at least it’s ready in case you find that TV one day
Ba-dun-tis
An alternative headline is that a woman was nearly burned alive after being misdiagnosed.
Reading the article, it doesn’t seem like a misdiagnosis. She showed all the signs of brain death and her chances of living were basically zero. Her family decided to start making preparations. When her body was being delivered back in an ambulance, they hit a pothole that jolted her brain back into action. Genuinely crazy medical story, but with 8,000,000,000 people on earth, this happening to at least one person is all but guaranteed.
Brain dead diagnosis is not very scientific based.
Not really. And let me explain.
You can see if there is electrical activity signals , you can do a fMRI scan (shows blood usage which indicates changes in cognitive processing. Most brains show patterns of blood use when doing tasks).
But. When you are unconscious, these always show low activity.
It’s not really that much different than someone being under anesthesia. They show the same pattern of brain activity as someone in a coma.
Now sometimes there is specific abnormalities for an injured region. But this just tells you that part of the brain is damaged. It doesn’t tell us if the person will regain consciousness
Awareness (consciousness in this definition) is controlled by a specific area in the mid brain (just north of the brain stem) called the renticular activating system.
Damage to this system is considered more conclusive brain death but that’s rare because of where it is. But it can still happen.
Actually interesting fact, anesthesia is used to study locked-in and “brain dead,” patients. Lots of ongoing research.
Anywho. There is a lot of controversy about what counts as brain dead. And how to distinguish , objectively with tests, from locked-in syndrome. Which is like being aware but being 100% paralyzed.
But one way you can be 100 % sure someone is brain dead is you keep them alive for 6 months to a year. And you compare their white matter scans from a MRI from start to that time.
For those who won’t be coming back, they will show pretty fast white matter loss generally everywhere.
Because the brain works like a muscle. Use it or lose it. And a loss that fast means nothing , literally no cognitive or perception processing, is occurring.
But as you can imagine there are ethical issues for that too and , financial ones.
Often if the patient shows no changes in electrical activity and no awareness for a few weeks or so, the general conclusion is they won’t be recovering.
Not exactly a reliable conclusion.
Lovely reply, thank you for taking the time to educate us.
There was a woman in the 90s who was brain dead and kept alive by life support for many years. It was controversial because her husband wanted to remove her feeding tube but her parents objected. Legally. Long drawn out legal battle from 1990 to 2005.
Anywho.
Here is an image of her brain scan. A CT. Not a MRI. But you can get similar info.
The dark areas are empty fluid filled.
White band around the head is the skull. Didn’t know the skull could thicken with brain loss but I suspect that’s a rare thing since people aren’t typically kept alive that long with a shrinking brain.
Anyway.
You can see comparison of image taken in 2002 after being in her state (1990) for 12 years compared to an average brain of her peer (female of same age).
Her brain weighed about half as much as it should have.
She was finally allowed to die in 2005.
https://pmc.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/articles/PMC558485/
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Terri_Schiavo_case
Depending on your age and if you are in the U.S or not. You might remember hearing about her.
I thought when you’re under anesthesia, your brain activity has a rhythmic wave pattern that blocks communication. Scans show that hearing and other senses are active but not recorded basically.
So neural oscillations, also known as brain waves, are constant in a live brain.
The frequency (how fast the waves are) of these oscillations changes based on activity and location . Being awake or asleep, doing a demanding task or not, if the task is audio or visual. Etc. )
When you are asleep there are different oscillations that you cycle through on a fairly predictable pattern.
However this can be altered by many things including drugs and medications. And health problems. Even environment stress and such.
When you are unconscious from anesthesia , you don’t get typical sleep pattern but different kinds of patterns. These are predictable too.
https://hms.harvard.edu/news-events/publications-archive/brain/anesthesia-brain
“According to Brown, anesthetic drugs cause brain circuits to change their oscillation patterns in particular ways, thereby preventing neurons in different brain regions from communicating with each other. The result is a loss of consciousness—an unnatural state that he compares to a “reversible coma”—that differs from sleep. The oscillations vary, he explains, based on the type and amount of anesthetic used and the age of the patient’s brain (since brains age at different rates). These powerful drugs can cause mental side effects that often linger for days, months or longer.”
https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Neural_oscillation
We are definitely getting into a more complex area of neuroscience.
https://www.frontiersin.org/journals/neuroscience/articles/10.3389/fnins.2025.1604173/full
This dense paper is on some recent research on locked-in patients and explains in the literature-review section how research on neural oscillations changed artificially with anesthesia has helped them more accurately investigate locked-in syndrome. Explains how these oscillations change in a coma state.
This is not my area of study. But if you have any simple questions about how this works I can probably answer them. Wikipedia might be more useful tho. The “Function” section is most informative.
If you read the article, it seems she was properly assessed as having no brain stem activity. Could be a cover up, who knows.
And they wouldn’t actually cremate her until there was no pulse. Unless they covered that up too!I mean obviously we only have the accounts of the article, but they claim her vitals were low, her Glasgow Coma Scale had dropped to a 3, and multiple tests showed she had neurotoxins in her system. It sounds like there are records to back up the claims being made. Obviously someone could always be lying, but it sounds like they’ve got the right info backing it up here.
Well, obviously, she was not properly assessed.
I mean, yeah. But did they actually do anything wrong, anything that any other doctors would have done?
Sounds like a X-file
Oooh, I know that one!
What’s UP highway?
Yo dude, wazzup wit you?
um two number 9s, a number 9 large, a number 6 with extra dip, a number 7, two number 45s, one with cheese, and a large soda.
Is that two biggie macs, a quarter pounder with cheese and a fillet o fish with extra fries?!
I’ve never heard of someone coming back from brain dead. Is this the first recorded case?
This somehow makes way for a “smack the patient in the face” medical treatment.
Do you know in the movies when they dramatically slam someone’s chest and yell “live damn it”?
That is called the precordial thump, and it used to be used in codes
Sometimes a good wallop is all someone needs
Percussive maintenance, now for people too!
Always has been
That’s what I call beating my children. Those mines aren’t going to dig themselves.
Fido, no! Landmines are unethical!
In ear and facial surgery where we use nerve monitoring, the surgeon will test for nerve activity by kinda just smacking the patient’s face and seeing if it makes the machine beep.
So, even the side of healthcare associated with finesse can just boil down to “punch em a bit”. Don’t even get me started in orthopedic surgery.
This precordial thump used to be part of my IT toolkit.
He’s dead, Jim!
For the same reason a good hard hit in the chest can stop your heart.
Also, the defib is doing something similar, it’s not shock starting your heart it’s trying to send a unified shock to get it all back in rhythm.
Medical beds should be built to automatically quickly lower someone to simulate hitting a big bump when vitals drop.
A glitch launches the patient instead. Possibly has the same results, plus or minus a few extra contusions.
Imagine how cool you’d feel if you revive someone with one of those
Arthur Fonzarelli, MD
I just figured it was extra-desperate CPR and never saw a reason to question its legitimacy.
Being fair it kind of is, which is why it’s not really used anymore.
It’s kind of “a 1% success chance is better than a 0% chance” type deal
I was 95% sure you were trolling, but holy shit
Considering that technique was discovered by hitting a pothole as well, maybe whomping from the back would be more effective. Or picking up and dropping the patient.
“Next week, on House…”
House! What are you doing?!
Dammit House, you got the right result the wrong way. Back to yer soaps with ya!
That actually was a method used in the olden times. Legit.
Not that it’s a good idea or that I would recommend the behaviour outside of extreme circumstances, but it can be useful for someone in shock to get them moving.
Bring back blowing smoke up their ass
if you get a funnel i got some smoke
I always wonder what the religious say about these events. Like, clearly, the person was dead at one point and should have pass on, no? So what is the religious answer to explaining why they’re alive again? 2nd wind? lol
“It wasn’t their time to go.”
“Mysterious Ways”
“God had bigger plans”
“He needed an angel here on earth”
“They’ve been possessed by the Devil!”
“He’s the son of God!”
“He’s been possessed by the Devil!”
cocks super shotgun “Shame.”
they also touched your bunny
The answer would be that she was not dead.
Dead is kind of a nebulous thing. The religious answer would obviously be it’s a miracle. In medicine there’s not really a way to tell the moment of death. It usually isn’t officially ruled until they give up trying to revive.
Doesn’t it mean they’re Jesus?
Was the doctor AI?
Reason #1 why we should put sick people into earthquake simulators.
A few good slaps should be enough
Potholes, ruins rims and apparently brings you back to life.
Man I clench my cheeks soo hard every I go over them either bike or car ride
I try to avoid them on my bike.
I try to avoid them in my car.
This is the equivalent of waking up from a coma via mallet to the head but even more unlikely.
The pothole is a powerful medical tool.
In the industry I’ve heard tell of it cardioverting patients out of SVT, killing patients with an AAA, and spilling the coffee of medics who were not vigilant about their drink discipline (SCMWWNVADD)
New Pfizer pothole gummies!
Delicious gummies, each with a little pothole in case you were falling a sleep at the wheel again… Larry!
pothole gummies
Sounds like a THC gummy so strong that it makes you unable to move, like a cannabis version of a K-hole.
Did that one of the few times I have consumed weed, would not recommend.
Got my revenge on the family member that fed me way too much (and used fucking hash mixed with frosting, which was disgusting) by puking on their bed a few hours later.
I’m going to assume K is for potassium.
Ketamine.
Ah.
