• InvalidName2@lemmy.zip
    link
    fedilink
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    12 minutes ago

    I wanted to sign-up using my preferred username. I won’t tell you what it is, because I might still eventually claim it down the line when that becomes an option, a portmanteau of two of my favorite characters’ names. Nothing crazy.

    The incredibly helpful and remarkably actionable error message that the buggy Lemmy UX/UI/validation gave me, “InvalidName”, was super useful in helping me figure out what I’d done wrong or what validation rules I’d broken.

    After many attempts to sign-up using different variations of my preferred username, I eventually gave up on trying to make a username that appealed to me.

    Then I defiantly decided to try “InvalidUsername” as my username. The green check mark came up again, I was good to go. Except when I submitted it, that was “InvalidName”, too. So I decided to try InvalidName2. Which the Lemmy Validation Gods accepted.

    The end.

    P.S. When the validation gives the user a green check mark, in most of the world, that would be interpreted as “this input is valid and correct and will work when submitted”. In the case of a user name, that would usually mean it fits all the requirements and limitations the system enforces and also includes a check to make sure it’s unique and can be claimed. In Lemmy-land, the green check mark means something, but clearly none of those things. It means other things. I just don’t know what, yet. Because the validation message doesn’t tell me and there’s no guidance on the sign-up page.