Ah, so that’s the context on that video. I ignored it due to the clickbait title and thumbnail. I’ve been ignoring a lot of his videos lately.
- 0 Posts
- 16 Comments
KeithD@lemmy.nzto
Technology@lemmy.world•Linus Torvalds used AI to fix a Linux bug, and now LLM critics on Linux face an uncomfortable choiceEnglish
1·10 days agoThis is a tool whose previous maintainers have apparently stopped working on it, not something that Linus was still involved in maintaining. This isn’t so much him wanting to step down, as him not wanting to step up if someone else with an interest in it might be willing to do so.
KeithD@lemmy.nzto
Technology@lemmy.world•Linus Torvalds used AI to fix a Linux bug, and now LLM critics on Linux face an uncomfortable choiceEnglish
2·11 days agoI don’t think that’s true in the way you appear to mean (sorry if I misunderstood). People who are already experts on the subject matter might be able to use better keywords and discard hallucinatory material quicker, but I don’t believe that you can generically “be good at prompting” outside of an area where you have substantial domain knowledge.
There are ways of phrasing LLM requests that can actively induce them to give you made-up bullshit that confirms your pre-existing assumptions. Which is fine if that’s what you want it to produce, but often not what people actually want. For (possibly poor, given I don’t actually use LLMs) example “give me the transcripts for five court cases for assault with a deadly fish” would likely result in five-ish almost-certainly made-up court transcripts. Someone who knows what they’re doing could phrase the prompt to be more likely to say that no such cases exist (assuming no such cases actually exist) instead of just hallucinating them as per the request.
And you might be right about domain knowledge being required for good prompting. But it’s possible to have domain knowledge and still be terrible at asking for what you actually want it to produce.
not to mention that they’re an “intern” who actually costs the same in computing power as two senior engineers’ salary.
Don’t expect me to defend the moronic economic decisions of companies that have jumped on this stupid band-wagon without regard for the actual value (or lack thereof) to their business.
KeithD@lemmy.nzto
Technology@lemmy.world•Linus Torvalds used AI to fix a Linux bug, and now LLM critics on Linux face an uncomfortable choiceEnglish
8·11 days agoI especially like his most recent use of LLMs.
Specifically as a threat to induce someone else to step up as a maintainer of the debug tool sparse.
KeithD@lemmy.nzto
Technology@lemmy.world•Linus Torvalds used AI to fix a Linux bug, and now LLM critics on Linux face an uncomfortable choiceEnglish
31·11 days agoGood point. I probably should have stated “using LLMs for technical tasks that anyone cares about the results of”.
I’m not going to claim LLMs are trustworthy, but I am saying that there are ways to ask things that either reduce the odds of it giving you false things or actively cause it to provide wrong answers with misstated or hallucinated context. People who know what they’re doing can get better results out of them. This doesn’t stop them from being the equivalent of a nepo-hire intern, but it could be said to change whether they’re a malicious, apathetic, or semi-eager nepo-hire intern.
And one of the big risks with LLMs is staff who can recognise bullshit or questionable results being replaced with staff who unquestioningly accept whatever results they get. And people reading an “AI summary” of something and assuming it’s actually accurate.
KeithD@lemmy.nzto
Technology@lemmy.world•Linus Torvalds used AI to fix a Linux bug, and now LLM critics on Linux face an uncomfortable choiceEnglish
51·11 days agoWriting an appropriate prompt is a skill. Many (most?) people using LLMs aren’t using prompts that give them what they actually want, in many cases because they don’t understand the thing they’re trying to ask for, but also in many cases because they don’t know how to ask for it while avoiding the many possible pitfalls that come with uncareful prompts (including, but not limited to, hallucination and bias).
Personally I haven’t bothered learning that skill yet, largely because I don’t want that crap shoved in my face all the damned time, and have little use for it anyway. But it’s still a skill.
KeithD@lemmy.nzto
Technology@lemmy.world•Flock CEO calls for ‘compromise’ as surveillance company faces growing backlash | TechCrunchEnglish
22·20 days agoI propose they compromise by going out of business after deleting all data and removing their cameras from everywhere.
KeithD@lemmy.nzto
Ask Lemmy@lemmy.world•You randomly get a free 50k no catch what do you do with it?
1·26 days agoMight want to save most of it for your next memory upgrade too.
KeithD@lemmy.nzto
Technology@lemmy.world•New sodium-ion battery skips mechanical cooling with 97.9% efficiencyEnglish
3·1 month agoIt’s close enough to already be in use in some chinese cars. But definitely better for stationary use cases where density matters less.
KeithD@lemmy.nzto
Technology@lemmy.world•New sodium-ion battery skips mechanical cooling with 97.9% efficiencyEnglish
6·1 month agoOr gallium hydride? GaH.
KeithD@lemmy.nzto
Ask Lemmy@lemmy.world•What Youtubers did you drop, And what caused you to do so?
2·1 month agoI think Karl and Ian had a falling out over Ian’s desire to avoid politics, not over his politics per se. I haven’t seen anything lately than suggests they ever hang out anymore. Ian still goes to shooting events Karl is involved in, I think, so it can’t be too acrimonious.
KeithD@lemmy.nzto
Ask Lemmy@lemmy.world•What Youtubers did you drop, And what caused you to do so?
28·1 month agoMeidas Touch. Clickbait headlines and thumbnails, unrealistically optimistic takes on things. I want information, not bullshit.
KeithD@lemmy.nzto
Technology@lemmy.world•GrapheneOS says Revolut is blocking its users over Google Play checksEnglish
3·1 month agoNot sure about them, but some banks have more features on the phone app than on the web. Bloody annoying.
In my day we used to know fuck all about shit. But kids these days…
KeithD@lemmy.nzto
Not The Onion@lemmy.world•Man arrested after 'dressing as Grim Reaper' at hospital and staring at patientsEnglish
3·1 month agoAren’t the rural hospitals all heading towards closure due to changes in medicare/medicaid funding? I’m pretty sure you’re just in the new normal.


Unlike a whole bunch of republican reps and staffers.